Friday 6 November 2015

PLAY IT AGAIN SAM

Or not maybe? The inevitable news that Sam Burgess will leave Bath and return to Sydney and the Rabbitohs after less than a year in English Rugby Union leaves egg on many faces. First, let's remind ourselves that Sam is only 26 and was offered an amazing financial deal by the RFU, sorry, Bath Rugby Club, to move over to England and switch codes. Very few players would have turned it down, especially as there was a strong hint that he might be helicoptered straight into the England RWC squad for 2019, sorry, 2015. Second, he obviously missed his family in Australia (his three brothers all play rugby there), and working in England whilst marrying his Australian girlfriend in Sydney in December was never ideal (she works there as well). Third, he somehow seems to have copped a large amount of the blame for England's abject performance over the last six weeks, sorry, four weeks, as they only lasted that long. This is unfair and lazy analysis from people who know better.

Okay, its egg time, it is now clear that Stuart Lancaster and his coaching team, mainly Andy Farrell, saw Sam as a perfect replacement for the injured Manu Tuilagi in the centre for England for RWC 2015, not four years time, which everyone agreed would be the necessary timetable required to get him up to speed with the different code. Rumours were he almost became the RFU's first centrally contracted player, but when Bath got involved, they were forced to stump up all the money required to bring him over (not sure how they managed it within the Premiership salary cap, but, hey, who cares), as their Premiership rivals rightly complained at any RFU assistance. The flaw in the plan was that Bath already had two world class centres in Eastmond and Joseph, and having experimented with Sam in that position, then moved him to back row, where his "slammin" ball carrying ability could be more effective. Everyone seemed mesmerized by Sam, referring to him as "the greatest rugby player on the planet" and indicating that anyone who has his own TV show in Australia, could turn anything to gold.

Sam Burgess
Sam with his Mum and brothers
So, after just a half season with Bath, he was propelled into the England RWC squad as a centre, at the expense of Luther Burrell, Kyle Eastmond and Billy Twelvetrees, and eventually, after JJ's injury, became first pick against Wales, at the expense of Henry Slade. To be fair, England did not fall apart in that game until he was substituted. However, it is madness to think that anyone could master the game of Union after just 20 games, and only one full international friendly - even Andy Farrell, Henry Paul, Iestyn Harris or Benji Marshall couldn't make the transition after playing more games in the same position. In fact, Sonny Bill is the only success story, and he has been around for some time learning his trade. Also, did they forget that Sam is a Rugby League prop, arguably the best League prop there has ever been, but this is Union and he was up against such quality centres as Roberts, Kuridrani, Nonu, Giteau, Smith and North. What the impact will be on those who failed to manage Sam during his short Union career remains to be seen, and, hopefully, communication between RFU and the Premiership Clubs will also be reviewed, as the respective agendas have never seemed more at odds.

Sam Burgess - Burgess rugby clan in different league to the Brownlee brothers
A young Sam
So, farewell Sam, writing a blog without you will be less exciting, and hope the return to Rugby League and family down under work out well for you.

Monday 2 November 2015

RWC 2015 FINAL EXTRA

Only in rugby, could two events make the front pages from yesterday's scintillating final. The first was the 14 year old boy, Charlie Lines, being tackled by the steward after the game as he ran on the pitch to greet Sonny Bill and colleagues. Not only did Sonny Bill, the former heavyweight boxer, pick him up and see off the steward, he then gave him his winner's medal. An amazing spontaneous gesture from a professional sportsman. Luckily, World Rugby managed to find another one in the cupboard, so SBW won't lose out. Hope Charlie sells it on eBay for charity in a few years time!

Image result for charlie lines tackle
Your head is in the wrong position for a tackle
The other, missed by most watching the game in the stadium or at home, was that Dan "God" Carter successfully converted the final try with his wrong foot (he is naturally left footed). He had been practising these apparently, and always wanted the opportunity to have a go. Only Dan Carter would have the audacity and confidence to use the RWC Final as such an occasion (and be successful). There are some that would say Jonny Wilkinson could naturally kick off either foot, and did not have a weak one, but even he favoured his left. And Dan Carter has officially taken over his "God" status, alright?

Image result for dan carter right foot
The Foot of God

RWC 2015 HIGHLIGHTS

Best Game

Japan v South Africa, by a country mile, if only I had watched it live or even taped the whole game. Japan's patience and accuracy under pressure in that last 5 mins to score the winning try was impressive - other countries should watch and learn.

Best Player

A toss up between many Kiwi's, Argentinians, a few South Africans and Aussies, but I think David Pocock was the most consistent performer and put his head and limbs in places few would.

Image result for david pocock world cup
Ouch..
Best Comeback

I think statistically it was Romania against Canada, but I personally want to give this to Scotland, who having conceded five tries against the Aussies, scored under the posts with seven minutes to go take the lead. Marvellous stuff, despite the dodgy penalty decision a few minutes later.

Image result for mark bennett australia world cup
It's raining, don't you just love rain...
Biggest Choke

Apologies it has to be England against Wales, who, having been so dominant in the first 65 mins of the game, only to fall behind to a great Welsh try, then contrive to ignore a penalty to draw the game (which would have been good enough to get out of the group) and mess up the lineout 10 yards out. So, the Welsh may have cheated slightly to get the ball out of play, but the decision to throw the ball to the front was always a risk and easy to defend.

Biggest "Out Of Jail" Moment

There were many, including Australia winning and kicking that penalty against Scotland, but I think New Zealand's ability to constantly slow the ball down at the breakdown, and not get penalised by the ref is admirable. Even in the final, McCaw, Kaino and Read were always slow to roll away from the breakdown, or interfering with the scrum half, sometimes causing Genia to climb over them like a kids playground, losing balance, before passing the ball away. Nigel Owens, like all the refs, obviously wants to keep play flowing, but as NZ know they will get the benefit of the doubt, they do it everytime without sanction, with the result that Australia, or any team playing NZ, never get quick ball and put them under pressure. This has to be looked at - McCaw has only been carded three times in his whole international career, once during this tournament, for a deliberate trip. The refs have to grow bigger balls and deter this cynical behaviour by penalising it immediately, regardless of the offender. Only then will teams get the quicker ball everyone wants to see, put defences under real pressure and score more tries (even against the All Blacks).

Image result for richie mccaw on floor
Remember Ritchie, support your own weight

ROVING REPORT: AUSTRALIA V NEW ZEALAND (THE FINAL)

Okay, I was not at the match but I did watch it live in an Irish bar and have watched the highlights again since.

New Zealand victorious, the top ranked team in the world, the team that has only lost three games since RWC 2011, with all their best players fit and on form, deservedly won RWC 2015 beating a spirited, brave Australian team, which has improved immeasurably in the year that Cheika has been coaching them.

The first half really decided the game. Australia were strangely nervous, muted and inaccurate, whereas New Zealand, with Carter at his most calm, clinical and ruthless were unsurprisingly dominant and led by 13 points at half time. The NZ try by Milner-Skudder in the corner summed up why they have been the best team by far over the last eight years. There was a hint of obstruction leading up to the last phase, but he simply walked over the tryline untouched to score, as a result of the ability of the men inside him fixing defenders and creating space for others. Both forwards and backs were involved, all playing heads up rugby and nobody taking the ball on too far, always executing the timing of the pass perfectly, committing the defender to make the tackle, and not taking contact. As a coach, it was breathtaking, it looks simple, it isn't.

Image result for milner-skudder try final
Look no defenders...
Australia then conceded a second try to Nonu's individual brilliance, running the ball in unopposed, with four defenders failing to lay a hand on him. This left Oz with a mountain to climb, but, thanks to heroics from Pocock and Hooper in the back row, they started to dominate the contact area, retain possession, build pressure and go through the phases, and after Smith was unnecessarily sin binned for a tip tackle (the first yellow ever in a final), they scored tries through Pocock and Kuridrani to cut the gap to just four points and it was game on.

NZ has always that ability to soak up pressure and find that sixth gear to seize the initiative back from teams that get close to them on the scoreboard. Dan "Superman" Carter did just that, stroking a drop goal over from the 10 yard line and then kicking over a penalty from inside his own half. As Australia chased the game, bodies tired and the play became more open, Mitchell turned the ball over in the NZ 22, and the best counter attacking team ever, funny enough delivered the coup de grace by scoring a breakaway try to seal the win, and their place in history as the first team ever to win consecutive World Cups.

It was a great contest, especially in the second half, and all credit to Australia for getting back to within once score (very few teams would have done so), but the best team (probably ever) won and, despite losing some superstars to retirement, who would bet against them retaining the trophy in Japan in four years time.

Image result for new zealand rugby final
When will we see their like again?