Wednesday 25 September 2019

WHO WILL ISSUE THE FIRST RED CARD?

Radio DJ's used to call it the hit parade, but it had nothing to do with the game of rugby ... until now. World Rugby sent out a clear message prior to the start of RWC 2019 in Japan that it would clamp down hard on illegal "hits" - high, no arms tackles - and that referees would be encouraged to issue a straight red if warranted. Well that has worked out well ... for some reason ever since the Australian Hodge's shoulder to the head assault on the Fiji back rower (no card, later cited), all RWC referees seem reluctant to issue the ketchup (red card) preferring the mustard (yellow card).


The hit parade is on a roll .. whether it is England v Tonga with Zane Kapeli’s big hit on Billy Vunipola which achieved the rare feat of knocking the No.8 backwards. The tackle was actually illegal and should have been penalised as Kapeli made the tackle with his shoulder while keeping his right arm tucked by his side. 

Or, how about the Russia v Samoa match, where twice in the space of a few minutes during the first half, Samoan players Rey Lee-lo and Motu Matu’u made the kind of hits that were clear ketchup offences. Not only were the tackles to the head, they were forceful and the tackler did not properly wraps his arms around his opponent, who in both cases, was the Russia captain Vasily Artemyev. 


The referee after consulting the TMO downgraded the offence to mustard only as they thought the player had lowered his head (complete b*****). Funny enough both players have been cited. Later in the same match Russia’s Kirill Gotovtsev grabbed Samoa’s Afaesetiti Amosa around the neck in an attempt to stop a certain try. The tackler wrenched Amosa’s head violently to one side causing a hyper extension of his right leg which led to a tournament ending knee injury. Again, mustard was shown not ketchup.

How strange that football, a much less dangerous game than rugby, should be far better at protecting the most skilful players. Still, there is time, with five weeks remaining of the tournament, for the referees to wake up and start throwing the ketchup about.

Tuesday 24 September 2019

RWC 2019: WEEKEND #1 REVIEW

So what did we learn about each team during the opening weekend of RWC 2019 in Japan?

In terms of Tier 1 clashes, New Zealand edged a titanic tussle with South Africa, France likewise against Argentina, whereas Ireland dominated a poor Scotland team, and Australia finally stretched away from a impressive Fiji. In the other games, England scored four tries, getting the bonus point against Tonga but have room to improve, Wales likewise against Georgia and Japan and Italy finally stretched away from a dogged Russia and Namibia respectively.

England's Samoan scored two tries against fellow Pacific Islanders

There was plenty of controversy involving referees and their application of the laws (or lack of). Reece Hodge somehow stayed on the pitch after his his high no arms shoulder charge on Yato, Fiji's best player, who did leave the field permanently (after failing an HIA). Hodge has since been cited (quelle surprise). South Africa were so incensed with the French referee's refusal to penalise NZ for persistently dropping scrums, clearing out rucks from the side, off their feet with no use of arms, that they made a nice video to show everyone. Manu Tuilagi on the charge for England


The Kiwis have been masters of the dark arts for years, and were very smart and clinical at the weekend. Yes, they cheat, but they do it better than anyone else - Richie McCaw's middle name was "lazy rolling away".

So it's award time, who got what?

Team super heroes: Fiji, Tonga, NZ (they are still the best) and France (for making the QF's despite everyone writing them off).

Team rubbish: Scotland, especially the forwards, and that Japan game (without Hamish Watson) now looks tight...
Ali Price thinking about that foot injury that will keep him out of rest of tournament for Scotland

Individual gold stars: Jordan Larmour (Ireland), James Ryan (Ireland), Damian Penaud (France), Antoine Dupont (France), Manu Tuilagi (England), Marika Koraibete (Australia), Sevu Reece (New Zealand), Zane Kapeli (Tonga).

Games to look forward to next weekend:

Ireland v Japan (could decide the group winners now Scots are recovering from Culloden#2),
Australia v Wales (again the group decider unless Fiji can beat the Welsh like they did in 2007...),
Scotland (or what's left) v Samoa (which Scots need to win to keep QF hopes alive).